AOA FOCUS logo

Federal judge certifies class action lawsuit against Hubble Contacts

October 19, 2026

Lawsuit alleges Hubble deceived customers into purchasing contact lenses their eye doctors never prescribed.

Tag(s): Advocacy, Patient Protection

A judge's gavel rests next to the scales of justice


Key Takeaways

  • A federal judge has certified a class action lawsuit alleging the company deceived consumers into purchasing contact lenses their eye doctors never prescribed. 
  • The ruling is a significant development in the lawsuit against Hubble, which was first filed in 2023. 
  • Hubble Contacts has been on the AOA’s radar for nearly a decade. The AOA has submitted more than 80 documented cases of suspected patient harm involving Hubble to the Federal Trade Commission. 
  • Doctors can support the AOA’s contact lens advocacy by reporting illegal sales or adverse events 

Hubble Contacts is coming under scrutiny—again. 

More than three years after the direct-to-consumer contact lens company faced a $3.5 million penalty and strict requirements to settle a federal complaint involving its prescription practices, a federal judge has certified a class action lawsuit alleging the company deceived consumers into purchasing contact lenses their eye doctors never prescribed. 

The ruling is a significant development in the lawsuit against Hubble, which was first filed in 2023. Until now, a single plaintiff, Wesley Africa, was pursuing claims on his own behalf. The class action certification makes it practical for other consumers to also pursue claims that could be financially prohibitive on their own. The ruling does not determine whether Hubble broke the law. 

The AOA has been raising serious concerns about Hubble’s practices for years, says AOA President Teri K. Geist, O.D. “Patients trust that the contact lenses they receive are the ones prescribed by their doctor of optometry, and that trust must never be compromised for commercial gain,” she says. “This ruling is an important step toward holding companies accountable and reinforces why strong safeguards are essential in protecting patients’ vision, eye health and safety.” 

Class action could impact thousands 

The lawsuit alleges that Hubble’s website asked customers only for their corrective power—not the brand or fitting measurements their eye doctors prescribed, according to Michael Sullivan & Associates LLP, the firm representing Wesley Africa. The company allegedly sought verification for its one-size-fits-all contact lenses using automated calls, according to the lawsuit, and, if there was no response within eight business hours, shipped its own lenses. The lawsuit alleges that customers received lenses that were different from what their doctors prescribed. 

California residents who purchased a subscription for Hubble Classic Daily lenses from hubblecontacts.com between April 25, 2019, and the present who were not prescribed Hubble Classic Daily lenses, and who do not seek personal injury damages, are eligible to be part of the class. More than 95,000 Californians purchased Hubble contacts during that period, according to court records, though not all will necessarily qualify for the class action. 

AOA’s advocacy brought scrutiny to Hubble’s practices 

Hubble Contacts has been on the AOA’s radar for nearly a decade. The AOA has submitted more than 80 documented cases of suspected patient harm involving Hubble to the Federal Trade Commission (FTC). 

In 2017, AOA sent letters to the Food and Drug Administration (FDA), the FTC and Department of Justice (DOJ) asking the agencies to investigate Hubble Contacts for possible irregularities related to prescription verifications for its contact lenses. The AOA’s concerns were validated the following year, when the business news website, Quartz, published an article titled, “Contact lens startup Hubble sold lenses with a fake prescription from a made-up doctor.” 

In 2022, the DOJ and FTC announced that the government would collect $1.5 million in civil penalties, $2 million in consumer redress and subject the online contact lens seller, Vision Path, Inc.—doing business as Hubble Contacts—to ongoing compliance monitoring and a full range of operating restrictions as part of a settlement to resolve allegations that the company repeatedly violated the Fairness to Contact Lens Consumers Act (FCLCA), the Contact Lens Rule and the FTC Act. That same year, the Texas attorney general and Vision Path, Inc., reached a settlement in which the company would pay $300,000 in civil penalties. 

The following year, the AOA Board communicated that the penalties were “not sufficient” after news broke that a woman was suing Hubble, claiming she purchased its contacts using an eyeglass prescription in 2020 and alleging that verification and provider information was not required at the time of order. The plaintiff alleged that, after wearing the contacts, she developed a “corneal ulcer and perforated multiorganism infection with near total melt and extrusion of lens,” believed to be derived from contact lens wear. The woman underwent a complete removal of her right eye. 

How doctors of optometry can help AOA’s advocacy 

Contact lenses are a safe, effective vision correction option when worn and cared for properly. However, poorly fitted or improperly used contact lenses can result in serious eye health and vision complications, which is why these FDA-regulated medical devices require oversight and prescription from an eye doctor. 

The AOA takes seriously its mission to serve as not only a reliable public source of information on issues affecting Americans’ eye health and vision care but also a resource for helping doctors safeguard their patients’ eyesight. The AOA regularly meets with federal regulatory officials to urge that more be done to crack down on dishonest internet and direct-to-consumer sellers, efforts bolstered by informed reports from doctors nationwide. 

Better documentation of illegal contact lens transactions helps the AOA build a case for increased enforcement by federal regulators. Here’s how doctors can support the AOA’s contact lens advocacy by reporting illegal sales or adverse events: 

Additionally, doctors are encouraged to complete this form when encountering such issues to arm the AOA with actionable data for regulators. For questions or more information, please contact StopIllegalCLs@aoa.org.