- Candidates announce 2025 election bids for AOA Board of Trustees
- Patient success stories drive awareness and action
- Introducing a brand-new member benefit
- Optometry’s Meeting gives students, recent grads a leg up in the field
- Rebuilding with Optometry’s Fund for Disaster Relief
- Advanced optometric education for an evolving scope of practice
- Case study: When doctor burnout becomes an ethical issue
- Cutting-edge education at Optometry’s Meeting 2025 in Minneapolis
- Optometry’s ‘pioneers’ come together to advance optometry
- 5 things to know about Optometry’s Meeting 2025
- Opportunities in Optometry Grants deliver fresh perspectives and enthusiasm
- ACOE Standards updates take effect: What they mean for optometric education programs
- Show off your unique cases, research at this year’s Optometry’s Meeting
- The AOA Foundation empowers optometry’s future in 2024
- AOA disaster fund provides shot in arm to devasted practices
- Seeding change
- New Year’s resolutions come to life at Optometry’s Meeting 2025
- Field Notes: Florida doctor recounts hurricanes Helene, Milton
- AOA Foundation makes emergency appeal for doctors, students in Helene-ravaged states
- AOA drives national discourse on optometry and importance of in-person eye care
- 4 steps you can take to be part of AOAs national pediatric eye health and vision mobilization
- ‘What more can I do:’ Change Agents ready to advance myopia care
- Deadline extended: Submit comments on AOA policy statement on telemedicine in optometry
- Eye Deserve More highlights power of the eye at groundbreaking NYC pop-up
- Leadership Institute advances leadership in the optometric profession
- ‘You can and will rise above’
- ACOE: Ensuring quality optometric education
- AOA president highlights importance of eye exams for classroom success
- AOA gathers optometry's leaders for open discussion on accreditation of continuing education
- Discover Music City
- Dangerous weather is on the horizon: what to know
- Optometry's Meeting Live News Updates 2024
- Fixin’ for a grand ole show at Optometry’s Meeting
- Interested in optometric clinical, scientific research?
- Candidates announce 2024 election bids for AOA Board of Trustees
- Seeing the Eclipse, and the AOA, Everywhere
- Optometric surgical procedures highlighted at this year’s Optometry’s Meeting
- Leading AI authority Tom Lawry to keynote Optometry’s Meeting
- ‘Change is the new status quo’
- Cranking up the volume on this year’s educational opportunities at Optometry’s Meeting
- Unlocking opportunities: Why you should attend Optometry's Meeting 2024
- AOA leaders resolute on advocacy priorities in 2024
- Eye Deserve More highlights eye health at work and play
- Call for abstracts now open: ePosters and Residency Forum
- Testing dates for paraoptometric certification set for 2024
- 20 stories that defined 2023
- Standing strong so others can rest from trauma, disasters
- Setting the tone for Optometry’s Meeting in Music City
- 3 events in 2023 that show why giving to InfantSEE is vital
- Through the eyes of students
- ‘Opportunities’ grants offer students and profession means to grow
- USDE approval could mark ACOE’s 71 years of continuous federal recognition
- Doctors of optometry on how to enjoy Oct. 14 eclipse in a safe way
- ‘Very close-knit community,’ Maui reckons with trauma of historic wildfires
- OptometryStudents.com refresher upgrades resource for future optometrists
- Have course ideas, will travel? Answer the AOA’s call for courses
- Historic and high-energy meeting of optometry’s minds
- Optometry's Meeting Live News Updates
- Optometry's Meeting News Page
- Discover the District
- Candidates announce 2023 election bids for AOA Board of Trustees
- Optometry’s Meeting® announces keynote speaker
- Developing tomorrow’s leaders
- Leaders Summit 2023
- call for abstracts
- Optometrys Meeting 2023 Keep up with contemporary optometry through continuing education
- FTC announces proposal ban on noncompete clauses
- 3 reasons to attend Optometry's Meeting 2023 in Washington, D.C.
- Eye Deserve More sees success
- ACOE’s rigorous accreditation process safeguards standards for optometric education
- Top 20
- help optometry weather the storm
- Voice Your Vision at Optometry’s Meeting in Washington, D.C.
- Raising optometry’s profile on influential panel
- AOAPlus aims for new heights
- The AOA team
- 2022 Opportunities in Optometry Grants
- ACOE expands council to manage increasing demands for residency programs
- AOA partners with professional game Jordan Fisher
- What members want AOA to prioritize
- AOA elects new Board of Trustees, approves resolutions, as Optometry’s Meeting 2022 wraps up
- AOA strong, optometry advancing leaders report from AOA Congress
- 2022 Optometrys Meeting open
- Shields up: U.S. health care system warned of Russian cyberthreat
- 5 reasons to attend Optometrys Meeting
- Save Your Vision Month 2022
- Collaborative courses OM
- Sign up for education-forward courses at Optometry’s Meeting 2022
- New ePoster format enhances participation, visibility of optometric research
- severe weather prompt renewed OFDR support
- 5 things AOA membership brought me
- Actions speak louder than words
- Eye Deserve More uses patient stories to reinforce the essential care doctors deliver
- AOA officers resolve to make 2022 most successful year yet
- Leadership Institute 2021 wrapup
- Save the date-Optometrys Meeting 2022
- ACOE accreditation: Ensuring optometric degree programs make the grade
- Opportunities in Optometry grant program makes difference for students
- projects fuel eye health vision care outreach
- Optometry's Fund for Disaster Relief Ida support
- CE, professional development for the 21st-century optometry practice
- Ida aftermath
- COVID-19 and a new school year
- Optometry Fund Disaster Relief is alway ready
- AOA campaign spreads the message that all deserve the care AOA doctors provide
- 2022 Call for Courses
- Seeing Beyond the Pandemic underscores criticality of children’s eye, vision care
- Optometry’s Meeting promise delivered
- AOA shares progress made toward diversity, equity and inclusion
- AOA Congress elects 2021-2022 Board of Trustees, approves resolutions
- Focus on recovery, renewal and the future at Optometry’s Meeting 2021
- Optometry’s Meeting 2021 reunites, reignites
- Explore the Optometrys Meeting host city of Denver
- Linenger named Optometrys Meeting keynote speaker
- Rethinking reimagining redoing how optometry learns
- Inaugural-Opportunities-in-Optometry-Grants-awarded
- OM2021 Education
- Optometrys Meeting 2021 Registration
- Diversity-Optometrys Reflection
- Optometrys Meeting 2021 changes venue
- Save Your Vision Month
- AOA launches Leadership Institute
- 2021 Leaders Summit recap
- AOA-AOSA Opportunities in Optometry Grant program
- AOA membership has benefits
- The most-read stories of 2020
- Doctors still making sacrifices as pandemic spreads
- House of Delgates-Successes amid very turbulent year
- Renee Brauns steps down
- HEHC grants support children’s vision projects
- Call for Courses
- COVID-19 recovery funds available for financially stressed doctors of optometry
- AOA secures optometrys access to 1.69 billion in COVID-19 relief
- Unprecedented human impact of western wildfires
- Defeating the debt
- AOA task force takes steps to open opportunities for doctors of color
- AOA launches new website
- AFOS celebrates five decades of delivering eye care through federal services
- HEHC community grants for eye health and vision care projects
- Dust cloud in the Gulf coast states
- Mask policy considerations for your practice
- AOA Foundation extends helping hand damaged practices
- AOA 2020 Virtual Learning Livecast
- focus earns gold circle award
- Doctors of optometry weigh how to hit the ground running once practices reopen
- Optometry Meeting canceled due to COVID-19
- Self-care in times of crisis
- AOA COVID-19 crisis relief recovery assistance
- Optometry elevating women
- Encourage patients to Start With Eye
- AOAPlus wants you in Washington
- patients see eye doctor in winter
- Improved care coordination doctor staff education
- Leaders Summit 2020 Advocacy
- hold companies accountable patients health
- Presidents Council
- cant miss continuing education opportunities at Optometrys Meeting 2020
- AOA membership strength in numbers
- 2020 moment into movement
- Top 20 stories in 2019
- Optometry Cares grant
- Optometry-Meeting-2020-calander-save-dates
- Optometry’s Fund for Disaster Relief eyes million mark
- InfantSEE student program stirs passion for pediatric care
- Mark McGrath to headline celebration at Optometrys Meeting 2020
- 2020-the year of the eye exam
- HEHC grants to children vision projects
- Championing childrens eye care
- Looking ahead
- AOA turning a moment into a movement
- Think About Your Eyes data shows eye care message received
- Optometrys Meeting 2019 Day 3
- Optometrys Meeting 2019 Day 2
- Change at the top
- Samuel D Pierce-Plotting a course
- Fathers Day-Hennen
- Hurricane Preparedness
- AOA is always on its media game
- United in Possibilities Gold Circle Award
- May is Healthy Vision Month
- AOA 2019 award winners
- 2019 National Optometry Hall of Fame Inductees
- NBEO settles class action lawsuit
- HPI Health Centers
- The Future is Female
- AOA’s 74th president, profession leader dies
- Bringing care to communities
- Optometrys Meeting-Johnny Cupcakes
- Saving vision is what we do
- AOA task force leads evolution of education for future of optometric practice
- AOA volunteers gather to plan for 2019 and big 2020 initiative
- Government shutdowns trickle-down effects
- Building for the future
- Care models of success
- 2018 most viewed stories
- Healthy Eyes Healthy Children grants program makes eye health and vision care a tradition
- InfantSEE program heartens students elevates pediatric care
- InfantSEE helps ensure a lifetime of healthy vision
- AOA Foundation fund provides relief for doctors of optometry after disasters
- High educational professional standards go hand-in-hand
- After disaster strikes
- In honor of Veterans
- Nutty Nutrition & Eye Health
- NOVA optometry school naming rights
- Surgeon General spotlights opioid abuse AOA offers doctors reference guide
- Florence eyes Carolinas doctors prepare for worst
- Learning for a lifetime
- 2018 HEHC grants go to children’s vision projects
- Redding doctor depicts historic wildfire
- Be involved
- Athlete endorsement boosts TAYEs connection to essential family health
- AOSA celebrates 50 years
- House of Delegates resolves action
- New AOA officers and trustees
- OM 2018 down to business
- Optometric Research Summit 2018
- Research Summit 2018
- opening 2018 Optometrys Meeting
- Passing the baton
- Kids vision project flourish
- Seamless transition ahead for AOA leadership
- Carving a career track with student loan debt
- Sunglasses slit-lamps among ophthalmic standards revisions
- Owning Save Your Vision Month
- JanFeb18_President
- 2018 Volunteer Meeting
- Educational Standards
- 2018 Presidents Council
- Mentoring supports next-gens
- 2017-most-read-Stories
- Think About Your Eyes caps off big year
- HEHC End of Year 2017
- InfantSEE program can make a difference to infants futures
- OFDRyear
- Aron Ralston
- The new doctor playbook
- Part of the solution
- Puerto Ricos dire situation
- Practice matters not place
- Recapturing the buzz of the inaugural AOAPLUS
- Howie Mandel
- Irma Aftermath
- Hurricane Irma Preparation
- HEHC grants
- Data Breach NBEO Lawsuit
- Harvey Stories
- UPDATE Hurricane Harvey leaves widespread devastation AOA leading donation effort
- Solar Eclipse Local ODs Outreach
- TAYE breakthrough commercials
- Solar eclipse protect those peepers
- VISION USA Pilot Rollout
- Hackwrap
- vision usa service awards
- highlights from Optometrys Meeting
- Optometrys Meeting wraps up
- OM in full swing
- Attendees dive in OM 2017
- AOAplus invigorates optometrys next generation
- Every doctor is an advocate
- Strong and stable AOA will transition leadership
- Stressing care in pediatric eye vision care
- AOA members make a difference through volunteer service
- AOAPlus on track to shatter attendance figures
- AOA headquarters renovation earns distinction
- Basketball national champion of sports eye injuries
- AOA emerging leaders experience
- Save Your Vision Month targets blue light blues
- AOA and US Postal Service partnering again
- Mind the gap do women docs make quarters on the dollar
- Optometrys advocates strategize to meet professional challenges ahead
- AOA Board local officials commemorate new headquarters facility
- During National Mentoring Month doctors of optometry pay it forward
- Profession leaders exchange best practices network
- Think About Your Eyes delivers results
- Top 20 AOA stories of 2016
- Support Archives Museum of Optometry
- Renovation of AOA national headquarters complete
- InfantSEE opens eyes of providers and parents
- Support VISION USA
- AOA leaders reinforce optometrys propatient message in nations capital
- Preserving optometrys heritage one frame at a time
- Colorblind fans flag NFL on jersey gaffe
- Vision USA helps doctors extend the power of their practice
- Renovation of AOA national headquarters now underway
- Campers experience arts and nature through senses other than sight
- ACOE seeks comment on standards revisions
- The art of collaboration
- River blindness treatment receives Nobel Prize
- optometry ranked no 10 among 20 best paying jobs for women
- Doctor of optometry explains the great dress debate
- Hymes Brauns appointed to top staff positions
- AOAs Renee Brauns named one of opticals most influential women
- Optometry's Meeting Live News Updates
- Optometry's Meeting Live News Updates
- Discover the District
Ruling allows lawsuit against NBEO to proceed
July 9, 2018
Doctors of optometry allege harm from 2016 security breach.
Tag(s): Inside Optometry, AOA News
A once-dismissed lawsuit by doctors of optometry against the National Board of Examiners in Optometry (NBEO) for its alleged role in a 2016 data breach can proceed after all, a federal appeals court ruled June 12.
Rhonda Hutton, O.D., and other doctors of optometry originally filed separate suits in August and September 2016. Their lawsuit, after their cases were combined, was thrown out by a district court in March 2017 because it ruled their allegations of harm were "speculative" and that the breach could not be traced to NBEO.
However, the 4th Circuit U.S. Court of Appeals disagreed last month with that lower court decision. Not only was injury sufficiently alleged by plaintiffs, the appeals court wrote, the judges also found grounds to conclude the breach could have originated with NBEO:
"The Complaints contain allegations demonstrating that it is both plausible and likely that a breach of the NBEO's database resulted in the fraudulent use of the Plaintiffs' personal information, resulting in their receipt of unsolicited Chase Amazon Visa credit cards." |
The appeals court decision means the Hutton lawsuit can go forward. NBEO has denied it is the source of the breach.
Liang case on hold
In a separate suit filed Aug. 14 in the U.S. District Court of Maryland, Brenda Liang, O.D., and others also sought class action status, alleging that NBEO, or a party within its control, failed to protect sensitive personal information—names, birthdates, Social Security numbers (SSNs), addresses or credit card information—of exam takers and others contained in NBEO's systems. The complaint goes on to claim that NBEO not only failed to provide notice of the breach to victims, but also denied its responsibility for the breach.
Brought forward by nine doctors of optometry and one student affected by the breach, the complaint alleged that NBEO is the only common thread among the parties and provides examples of financial harm suffered by the plaintiffs. The lawsuit seeks damages, restitution, attorneys' fees and injunctive relief.
"The fraud resulting from this data breach is as extensive as any data breach in history, with an alarming percentage of optometrists practicing in the United States having already suffered identity theft and fraud," the Liang complaint stated. "The damage resulting from this breach is extensive and ongoing."
In one case, a plaintiff reported three separate occasions where fraudsters applied for Chase Amazon Visa credit cards using her stolen personal information. Although all three applications were cancelled due to the plaintiff's diligence in freezing her credit, the plaintiff's credit card information was used to charge more than $1,800, a reloadable prepaid Visa was opened in her name and a fraudulent eBay order was placed.
In another case, the plaintiff alleges that she proactively and periodically contacted Chase to inquire about applications filed in her name. When the plaintiff learned of one such fraudulent application filed in her maiden name, she reported the fraud; however, she notes the "hard inquiry" from the fraudulent application still appears months after the fact, damaging her credit. It wasn't until April 2017 that the plaintiff learned of another fraudulent application using her maiden name and parents' address— which the plaintiff claims is the same information used to register with NBEO.
"She provided the Illinois Optometric Association and the American Optometric Association (AOA) with her new name after she was married in 2014, and she had updated her address with those organizations in 2013," the complaint alleges. "She never updated any of her information with NBEO because the board exams were long over and it seemed unnecessary as NBEO is not an active organization like AOA."
Moreover, after these fraudulent applications were filed, the plaintiff claims that she confirmed that NBEO still maintained her prior name and address in its systems.
Other plaintiffs' accounts note the combination of maiden/married names and outdated addresses, financial harm, expenses associated with credit monitoring services, and concern for sensitive personal information being sold on the internet.
It's believed that fraudsters stole personal information to take advantage of an Amazon.com promotion where enrollees for a Chase Amazon Vision credit card would receive $50 in their account. The complaint alleges fraudsters used victims' real information for the application, then linked the card to a false account to collect the money. But, subsequently, the fraud has expanded beyond these Chase Amazon cards and affected victims' other accounts.
The Liang case remains under a Dec. 18 stay order, pending the outcome of the Hutton lawsuit.
AOA advocates for doctors, students throughout
Amid the initial wave of malicious credit line openings circulating Aug. 2, 2016, the AOA immediately conducted its own internal investigation—finding no breach of its database—and began imploring affected parties to hedge against credit or financial damage. As the situation progressed, and it became clear that SSNs were the targeted personal information, then AOA President Andrea P. Thau, O.D., called on NBEO to issue reassurances that such personal data was protected.
Lacking any formal reply, AOA's Board of Trustees took additional action Oct. 8, appealing to other optometric organizations to petition optometric testing organizations over the elimination of SSNs as personal identifiers. Weeks later, NBEO announced it would discontinue use of SSNs in favor of a new 'OE Tracker number system' that addressed "contemporary global concerns about the challenges in protecting personal identifiers within all databases," the NBEO's TestPoints® newsletter stated.
At the time, Dr. Thau called the move a step in the right direction, adding: "[AOA] will continue to press for action, including federal investigation into the breach, to provide peace of mind for our members and colleagues."
In a letter to the U.S. Attorney General's Office, the AOA called for further Department of Justice investigation into the identity thefts in hopes of holding those responsible accountable. In the months since, AOA has relayed information, as it becomes apparent, to help mitigate concerns stemming from the data breach, including hosting a session with the FTC.
"The profession deserves to know as promptly as possible the sources and extent of the breach, and the remedy offered by the compromised party," said AOA Immediate Past President Christopher J. Quinn, O.D. "This has been our message from day one to law enforcement and federal agencies, as well as to any individual or any organization with knowledge of what occurred."
Affected by the data breach? Read more about protecting your identity from the FTC.